Monty hall problem

The Monty Hall problem explained

The Monty Hall problem is a classic probability puzzle based on a game show called Let’s Make a Deal. The problem is named after the show’s host, Monty Hall.

The Monty Hall problem refers to a statistical puzzle that can seem very counter-intuitive. Imagine you participate in a television show, and you are given the choice between three doors (A, B, and C). The host tells you that you will win whatever is behind the door of your choice. He also tells you that behind one of the doors is a new car, and behind the other two doors is a goat. Suppose you choose door A. Then the host (who knows what is behind each door) reveals that behind door C is a goat. You are then given the opportunity to switch to door B, or stick with your original choice. The question is: would that be a smart thing to do? That’s the Monty Hall problem.

Most people think that it does not matter: there is a 1/2 chance the car is behind door A, and a 1/2 chance that the car is behind door B. Most people are wrong… It actually does matter! The probability that the car is behind door B is actually 2/3, so it would be wise to switch. Confused? Let’s look at the math.

The solution to the Monty Hall problem

Why is it better to switch? Suppose I choose door A. There’s a 1/3 chance that this is the door with the car, so there’s a 2/3 chance that the car is behind door B or C. Then the host reveals that there’s a goat behind door C. Remember that the host knows what is behind each door, so he deliberately opens the one with the goat (or picks randomly if both of them have a goat). This revelation gives you new information (the car is not behind door C), so the probability of 2/3 that the car was behind door B or C is now transferred to door B only. The probability that you were right the first time stays 1/3, so you will double your chances if you switch to door B.

The Monty Hall problem

A more extreme example

Still confused? Then let’s look at a more extreme example. Suppose that in this version of the game, you have to choose 1 out of 100 doors. You pick door number 21, after which the host opens all the other doors to reveal goats, except door number 87. Would you switch in this case? Your intuition probably tells you that you should switch, which is indeed the right move.

When you choose door number 21, the probability that the car is behind that door equals 1/100. At this point, this probability is the same for all doors in the game. That means that the probability that the car behind one of the other doors is 99/100. Then the host opens 98 other doors to show there is no car behind them. Remember, the host knows where the car is, so he deliberately picks the ones that have a goat. As a result, the probability that the car is behind door 87 changes from 1/100 to 99/100, because all the other doors have been excluded.

The Monty Hall problem and Bayes Theorem

The Monty Hall problem can also be explained using Bayes Theorem. This theorem describes probabilities of an event, given another event occurs. In other words, it uses prior information (probability of a door hiding a car) and the likelihood of observed data (i.e. the probability that the host opens a particular door given the choice and the ). For a full explanation, see this webpage.

Conclusion

The Monty Hall problem is a classic probability puzzle. The solution may seem counterintuitive because it goes against our initial intuition. However, it is mathematically sound and has been demonstrated through various simulations and experiments.

2 thoughts on “The Monty Hall problem explained”

  1. It is 50 50 and look at this scenario ….
    Suppose you are playing a 100 door version of the game.
    You choose 33 doors, so your chance is 33/100 to win .
    Monty now opens 66 of the remaining doors to show you that there is no prize behind it.
    He then says, “Would you like to stick with the 33 doors you have chosen, or would you prefer to swap them for the one other door I have not opened ?
    ” What do you do?
    Do you stick with your 33 doors or do you make the 33 for 1 swap he is offering.
    The odds as the switch supporters claim is that sticking has 33/100 chance (frozen)
    but switching has 67/100 chance which is obviously higher (because revealed doors odds are shifted only to the unpicked door as “the switch is better supporters” claim).
    What a foolish choice to switch !!!

  2. The mistake that the switch has 2/3 odds in 3 door game is Making the assumption that
    The probability of (opening door 2 OR 3) = The probability of (opening door 2 AND 3)
    And I will explain it as follows:
    I will choose door 1 and I will stick with it .
    The options are (and this is the correct OR method i.e open 2 OR 3 played correctly ):

    Door1 door 2 door 3 result of sticking
    Prize opened closed win
    Prize closed opened win
    Goat prize opened loss
    Goat opened prize loss

    And you see that wins and losses are the same and it is 50 50.

    The mistake of the assumption I mentioned above in the game runs as follows ( and this is the wrong AND method not the OR method but assumed as OR method ):

    Door1 door 2 door 3 result of sticking
    Prize open OR? open win (This is open door2 AND door 3 NOT OR )
    Goat prize opened loss
    Goat opened prize loss

    And the switch has 2/3 odds.

    So the odds of opening door (2 or 3) does not equal the odds of opening (2 and 3)
    And this is the mistake always hidden in the method of the supporters of the 2/3 switch odds.

    Note: The only way to have a 2/3 chance by switching is when the host says : I allow you to switch to the other two doors TOGETHER and I will reveal an empty one of them and don’t say which door you want to switch to .Here clearly you have chosen two doors together and your pick is always the other closed door after host opens the empty door from the other two doors.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *